贺弋芷 · 雅思写作 Task 2 批改

两篇练习合批 | 日期:2026-08-12 | 教师:赵日 | 题型:大作文(议论文 / 报告类)

📌 两篇总评(先看这个)

预估总分:Essay 1 约 Band 6.5,Essay 2 约 Band 6.0。两篇的结构与审题是强项——四段框架完整、立场清晰、都有让步段,TR/CC 可达 6.5–7;主要失分在语法准确度与中式搭配(GR/LR 卡在 5.5–6)。Essay 2 比 Essay 1 语法错误更密集(含粘连句),故低半档。

共同优势:四段式框架完整(立论→主体→让步→结论),立场都清晰,且都写了让步段,词汇有"往上够"的野心(diabetes / cardiovascular / economic downturn)。

共同病灶(按优先级):

👉 结论:框架与审题已达 6.5–7 水平,真正的提分空间在"写对"——主谓一致、杜绝造词、少硬上倒装。把共性病灶清掉,Essay 1 稳 7、Essay 2 冲 6.5 完全可行。后面有「共性病灶」专章。

Essay 1 | 独居趋势

题目:More and more people choose to live on their own. What are the reasons people choose to do this? Is it a positive or negative trend?
TR 任务回应
7.0
CC 连贯衔接
7.0
LR 词汇
6.0
GRA 语法
6.0
预估总分
6.5

审题与连贯是强项(双 7),词汇与语法稳定在 6——个别句子翻车但不影响整体理解,属于"修掉错配就能上 7"的档位。

可保留 写得好的地方

  • 框架清楚:立论段立刻给立场("generally a positive trend, although…downsides"),主体讲原因、让步讲缺点、结论回扣——四段齐全。
  • 有让步段:Admittedly 引出孤独感与大城市成本,显得思考平衡,不一根筋。
  • 衔接词自然:First and foremost / Besides / However / In conclusion 用得位置对,不是硬堆。
  • 结尾有力:"the independence and personal growth it brings outweigh the disadvantages" 这句逻辑和用词都不错,建议原样保留。

需改进 逐句问题 + 修改

原句(问题处)问题修改建议
the desire for independence and owning self-alone space 造词:self-alone 不是词 …and personal space of their own / having their own space
live without accompany 词性:accompany 是动词,这里要名词 live without company(陪伴)
People's expectation … is intrigued by the freedom … at the time of living alone 动词误用:intrigued=好奇,语义错;短语生硬 This expectation is driven by the freedom to manage their time and space when living alone
Hardly had the young people imagined to determine by self in their wildest dream when they grew up and made a decision to live independently. 整句崩坏:倒装+ idiom 混用+ 逻辑矛盾("长大后"与"现已独立"冲突),不可读 In the past, young people rarely imagined they would one day make such independent choices on their own.(建议整句重写或删除)
enjoy the isolated time … enrich inner world … but it can boost their independence isolated 偏负面;缺物主代词;it 指代不清 enjoy solitary time / time alone … enrich their inner world … but this can also strengthen their independence
the cost … is quite high, which impose financial pressure 主谓一致:which 指 cost(单数) which imposes financial pressure on them
keeping in touch with families and friends 单复数: family 作集合名词通常单数 with family and friends

参考改写 约 Band 7 水平

Essay 1 · 参考版

An increasing number of young people now prefer to live by themselves rather than with family or roommates. In my view, this is generally a positive trend, despite a few drawbacks.

The main reason for this choice is the desire for independence and personal space. Living alone gives people the freedom to manage their own time and surroundings, which in turn helps them become more self-reliant. In solitary time, they can focus on developing skills and building a richer inner life, while also learning to take full responsibility for their daily decisions.

Admittedly, there are downsides. Living alone reduces social interaction, and some may feel lonely. Moreover, the high cost of housing in big cities places financial pressure on young people. However, these issues can be eased by staying in touch with family and friends and by learning to budget carefully.

In conclusion, although living alone has its shortcomings, the independence and personal growth it fosters outweigh the disadvantages. Overall, it is a positive trend.

Essay 2 | 对高糖食品征税

题目:To improve public health, governments should impose a high tax on sugary drinks and fast food. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
TR 任务回应
6.0
CC 连贯衔接
6.0
LR 词汇
5.5
GRA 语法
5.5
预估总分
6.0

立场与框架稳(TR/CC 6),但语法错误比 Essay 1 更密(粘连句 + 多处动词形式错),GR/LR 卡在 5.5——修掉这些冲 6.5 不难。

可保留 写得好的地方

  • 立场鲜明:首段直接 "I firmly believe … crucial and necessary",没有模棱两可。
  • 论证有层次:先讲健康危害(糖尿病/心血管),再从"价格敏感度"角度讲税收杠杆,逻辑链成立。
  • 有让步:承认"税收 alone 不够,还需健康教育",思考完整。
  • 主题词汇到位:diabetes / cardiovascular disease / economic downturn 用得对,是加分项,保留。

需改进 逐句问题 + 修改

原句(问题处)问题修改建议
the method of government to practically improve human-being's health 搭配/用词:method of government 生硬;practically 误用;human-being's 单复数怪 governments' approach to effectively improving public health
sugary food is a common trigger, which causing people suffering illness 缺谓语动词;suffering 搭配错 which causes illness / causes people to suffer from illness
these food lead to the form of diabetes food 不可数却加 these/lead;the form of 多余 this food leads to diabetes
under the period of economic downturn 介词错:under the period 不搭配 during economic downturns / in times of
governments impose a high tax … and fast food can be influential, which encourage people 粘连句(两Clause硬接);encourage 主谓不一致(应为 encourages) when governments impose a high tax …, it can be influential, encouraging people to choose healthier options
build up a habit to eatfalling the victims of excessively intaking 三连错:build up a habit 错;habit to eat 错;falling the victims 冠词/单复数错;intaking 非词 develop the habit of eatingfalling victim to excessive consumption / intake of
Combining with the cultivation to propel people's awareness 分词错(应为 Combined);cultivation/propel 搭配全错 Combined with efforts to raise / promote public awareness
impose a high tax on sugary drink in a bid to improving drink 应复数(呼应题目);in a bid to + 原形 sugary drinks in a bid to improve
injects new vitality into accumulating money … enhance another field accumulating money 不地道;语义模糊 raising revenue / generating funds that governments can invest in other public services

参考改写 约 Band 7 水平

Essay 2 · 参考版

Whether governments should impose a high tax on sugary drinks and fast food to improve public health has been widely debated. I firmly believe that such a tax is a necessary and effective measure.

The primary reason is that sugary products are a major cause of illness. As food production has expanded, a wide range of tasty but sugar-rich items has entered daily diets, contributing to diabetes and cardiovascular disease. Furthermore, during economic downturns, price strongly influences people's choices. A high tax on unhealthy food therefore encourages consumers to shift toward healthier options. Not only does this help individuals form better eating habits and save money, but the revenue raised can also fund public services.

Admittedly, taxation alone cannot fully solve public health problems. It must be combined with education to raise awareness of fitness and healthy living, which remains equally urgent.

In conclusion, I am convinced that a high tax on sugary drinks is significant for improving public health, while also generating funds that governments can invest in other areas.

🔧 共性病灶

共性 两篇一起犯的 4 个坑

  • 主谓一致(最高频):关系代词 which 后的动词总忘随先行词变。cost→imposes,tax→encourages/encouraging。写完一句,盯一眼"主语单数还是复数"。
  • 硬上倒装/强调翻车:Not only…but、Hardly… 这类结构,一旦用错比不用更扣分。Essay 1 那句直接崩成不可读。建议:先把简单陈述句写准,倒装留到非常有把握时。
  • 造词 / 错搭配:self-alone、intaking、cultivate awareness、build up a habit。积累固定搭配:raise awareness, form/develop a habit, live without company, impose financial pressure, raise revenue
  • 模板句依赖:"With the development of society" 两篇都开场,"From my perspective" 重复。Examiner 看多了会掉 TR 分。直接入题更好,例如 "An increasing number of young people now prefer to…"。

📚 下一步:把批改变成下一篇的分数

你空间里已有两份写作资料,本篇每一条"需改进"都能在里面找到正确版本,直接拿来用,别临场再造词。

工具箱 先背熟写作表达工具箱三张表

  • 万能论点库:里面有 raise public awareness,你这次写成了 cultivate awareness,直接换成这个就对了;还有 impose regulations、improve quality of life、alleviate stress 等 12 组,按话题塞进主题句。
  • 替换表:想写 good / bad / important / think 时,查表换成 beneficial / detrimental / crucial / argue,不要现编。
  • 四段式主体段固定三步:主题句 → 论证 → 举例。你结构已经很好,下一篇每段都按这三步走,保证有展开、不空。

6 篇 你刚写的两题,空间里早给了思路和词

  • 独居趋势 和 高糖食品征税 在写作大作文 6 篇 里都有:思路提示加高分替换词,例如 autonomy、social isolation、fiscal deterrent、state intervention、community cohesion。下笔前点开看一眼,把那些词直接用上,比硬凑 self-alone、intaking 稳得多。
  • 对照你这次的错:which imposes / encourages 解决主谓一致,falling victim to 你写成 falling the victims,in a bid to improve 你写成 improving,这些在工具箱句型里都是现成正确写法。

自测 写完用三问过一遍,专治本次失分点

  • 这句主语是谁、单数还是复数? 专治 which impose / which encourage 这类主谓不一致。
  • 这个动词形式对吗? 专治 in a bid to improving、falling the victims。
  • 这个词真是英语里有的搭配吗? 不确定就翻工具箱替换表,不猜。

提醒 倒装句先收一收

  • Not only…but、Hardly… 这类一旦写错比不写更扣分,你独居那篇那句直接崩了。先把简单陈述句写准,等有把握再上。
  • 下一篇小目标:不追求难词,只追求零主谓错误、零造词。